At-Home Dressing Room Diary: American Eagle

It’s time (again!) for another at-home dressing room diary. Did anyone else feel like Valentine’s/President’s Day sales rivaled Black Friday?! Some of the clothing deals were too good to pass up. For this round, I’m sharing what I found at American Eagle. I swear by AE denim, and I am occasionally able to find some cute tops as well. This order was placed with our upcoming California trip – we’re going in April! – in mind, and warmer weather in general.

For reference, I’m 5’7″ and 143-145 pounds. From AE, I typically waver between a small and medium for tops and a size 4 for pants/bottoms.

Long Sleeve Stripe Button Down Top

Color: Blue | Size: S (also tried M) | Verdict: Returning it

I first saw this top on someone else via Instagram and fell in love. Look at those beautiful buttons! This top is why I placed an order at all, but unfortunately it didn’t work out. The material is so heavy – you almost could wear it open as a utility-type jacket/top. The cut also is very boxy, which works when tucked into high-waisted bottoms, but overall it’s not my favorite/flattering on me.

At-Home Dressing Room Diary American Eagle - striped button down top

Tomgirl Pant

Color: Softest Jade | Size: 4 REG | Verdict: Going to exchange for a smaller size

These pants are ridiculously comfortable! It has been a long, long time since I’ve worn anything other than skinny jeans/jeggings and now I’ve seen the light. Doesn’t hurt that Ryan also loves these. 😉 This is the exact color green that I’ve been looking for, too. These pants will be perfect for spring/summer with a pair of sneakers or sandals. I am, however, going to try a size down since my normal size 4 seems pretty generous plus stretch!

AE Tomgirl pant in softest jade

Embroidered Knit T-Shirt Dress

Size: L (also tried M) | Verdict: Returning it

I wanted to love this dress. There were visions of strolling along Catalina Island in this dress. But, sadly – nope. The medium gives a more flattering shape overall, but the large has better length. It actually would make a cute coverup for the beach/pool, but I personally wouldn’t feel comfortable wearing it on it’s own.

AE Embroidered Tshirt Dress

P.S. the dress isn’t dirty with white spots … that would be my mirror. Oops.

Ne(x)t Level High-Waisted Mini Skirt

Color: Dream Blue | Size: 4 (also tried 2) | Verdict: Returning it

A denim skirt is another thing I’ve long coveted. I mean, hello – those were my jam during my teenage years. I actually love the overall fit and look of this jean skirt; however, it’s just too short for my old-ass self. Maybe I should try it in a tall size? It also seemed to ride up every two seconds while walking, so maybe it just doesn’t work for me and my body type.

AE next level high-waisted denim mini skirt

Ahhmazingly Soft Colorblock Hoodie

Color: Blush | Size: M | Verdict: Undecided

The last thing I probably need is another sweatshirt, but given where I live I wear them year round! I thought the color combination of this one was so cute – I’m only undecided because I’m not sure the blush works on me. Otherwise, this sweatshirt is so soft and is a good in-between weight of warm enough. I might be able to size down to a small for a more fitted look, but I do like more room in sweatshirts so the medium still works.

AE coloblock hoodie in blush
Unfortunately a majority of my order is going back, but that’s just the way it works sometimes. I still think all of these styles are really cute for the upcoming warmer seasons, so I hope some of you will be able to order yourself something or get a little inspiration!

Have you found anything lately at AE? Any upcoming travels? Share with me in the comments!

Don’t forget my latest Loft dressing room diary!

Say something ...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. I love all your AE finds!! SO cute friend!!

    Posted 2.26.19 Reply
    • Karly wrote:

      They have some super cute stuff right now, I wish more of it would’ve worked out for me!

      Posted 3.1.19 Reply
  2. Brittany wrote:

    I am loving those green pants!! So fun for when you’re bored with winter clothes & they’ll be perfect for spring! Also – I vote yes on the sweatshirt 🙂

    Brittany |

    Posted 2.25.19 Reply
    • Karly wrote:

      Right?! Honestly, anything other than classic denim skinnies/jeggings are so outside my comfort zone so I’m amazed that I love those pants as much as I do!

      Posted 3.1.19 Reply
  3. Biana wrote:

    I like the blush color on you – I think you should keep the sweatshirt!

    Posted 2.25.19 Reply
    • Karly wrote:

      Thanks for the help, girl!

      Posted 3.1.19 Reply
  4. Alissa wrote:

    Okay I haven’t been to AE since high school but the other day I saw them and I was like wait, this is cute?! You make it look even better Karly!

    The Adored Life

    Posted 2.25.19 Reply
    • Karly wrote:

      Awe, thanks Alissa! Their styles have definitely changed in recent years – I worked there in college, and it was not the same back then!

      Posted 3.1.19 Reply
  5. cara wrote:

    Even though you’re returning a lot of it, it all still looks super cute on you! I actually really like the blush hoodie and those tom girl pants are soo cute. I’m a huge fan of boyfriend style jeans, so I love those. Quick question- What company did you go through for presets? I’ve been looking into them lately.

    Posted 2.25.19 Reply
    • Karly wrote:

      I was bummed that I returned practically everything, but finding those pants made the order worth it! I’ve been using the Light and Airy Photography Mobile presets – I found these girls through Instagram, and their filters are so easy to use!

      Posted 3.1.19 Reply
  6. Debbie wrote:

    You found lots of cute things that will be perfect for your trip!

    Posted 2.25.19 Reply
    • Karly wrote:

      I wish I would’ve kept more of it!

      Posted 3.1.19 Reply
  7. Samantha wrote:

    Love this brand! So many cute looks.

    Posted 2.25.19 Reply
    • Karly wrote:

      Definitely some gems from AE!

      Posted 3.1.19 Reply

lately on instagram @whatkarlysaid

  • To my #foreverweddingdate: thanks for always standing by my side, letting me dress you up once in a while, and posing for pictures outside my childhood home like it’s high school graduation day. I love you so much. 😂❤️ #marriedlife #fridayfeels
  • It has been 84 years since it stopped raining in Wisconsin, so it seemed necessary to document the occasion. 💁🏼‍♀️ #thursdayvibes #loveloft
  • #Bookworms, rejoice! This is our kinda day! 📚 On #WorldBookDay, I simply want to say thank you to all authors. Your characters, stories and words change my life daily, and I can’t imagine a life without them. Happy reading to all! #bookstagram
  • “It’s no use going back to yesterday, because I was a different person then.” Alice, Alice in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll
@Disneyland is full of hidden scenes and little details. This area in particular, right around the corner from Fantasyland, was my favorite of them all! Maybe because we were there early before the crowds came pouring in, or maybe I was taking a moment to be nostalgic ... either way this was the first time in a few months that I felt happy and 100% myself. Perhaps that’s the magic of Disney that Walt always talked about.  #adultsatdisney #disneyland
Do you ever experience quiet moments of total content while on vacation, no matter where you are?
  • Catalina Island is nothing short of enchanting. ☀️ #catalinacasino #vacationmode #frommyview
  • California vacation part one: ☑️. Thanks for the magic, memories and OG nostalgia Disneyland! #adultsatdisney #toontown #wallsofdisney